Winning by Name

Agreed! The best by a country mile!

Captain of one of only two cup-winning teams, there is no way he wont be in the Hall of Fame eventually.

With probably the best two (McKenna and Souttar) out and Halkett now as well. I would say no-one is any better than Gallagher - some are definitely worse. His good form isn't just this season with us, he was excellent last year with Livingson too.

Lets through in a real had grenade - Alan Hutton and Ross Wallace as our two full backs. Just to see the reaction!

Neither opinion is wrong, they are both understandable. It is very understandable that a young player has an opportunity to move on and increase his earnings etc; it is also understandable that many fans believe he should have returned the resources and opportunities offered by Motherwell and stayed for a few years. I will get down of the fence now as my arse is getting sore.

Totally agree. Polwarth has been one of our best players.

I think that Carson is deserving of his chance.

I would have thought that Gallagher is exactly that

We haven't even signed him and he is getting pelters. Why do we do this? I seem to remember Bury fans thought Tom Aldred was the worst centre back of all time and he turned out not too bad.

If we don't think its a risk worth taking we shouldn't complain when the old firm come calling.

I don't have the answer to this but in some way clubs like us have to take a risk and offer longer contracts earlier on in the development of players like Turnbull and Hastie. Its a risk though.

I think if Robinson didn't play Carson against Annan he wont play him against Hearts. Unless Carson is getting fitter / healthier all the time and may be seen as ready now. If SR doesn't feel that yet I don't think he will play Carson (which I would agree with).

Andy Powell and his Flying V guitar!

I know I don't know how that happened, fixed it now apparently

You win some you lose some We just lost that one.