Dundee Utd

[Andy_P]

Your thoughts and votes please....

[Jonesy]

Randolph no question. Had little to do for the first 60 mins, but had some tremendous saves towards the end.

 

Carswell had a good 1st half but lost his way in the 2nd. Everyone else was rank.

 

EDIT: Perhaps should add ZFA and Faddy looked sharp enough when they came on. But with little or no movement around them there was only so much they could do.

[underboyleheating]

Randolph for keeping us in the match.

[joewarkfanclub]

Randolph.

 

Kept it from being a much bigger score towards the end.

 

No outfield player got close.

[Well 4 Europe]

Can only be Randolph.

 

Flapped at a few crosses which was out of character, however he made three stunning saves in about 5 mins that kept us in it.

 

If everybody was a 7 or above on Saturday everybody was a 6 or below tonight. Although I thought Carswell did put in another decent shift but when we needed a goal and some creativity he maybe should have been the one sacrificed.

[steelboy]

i thought all the saves randolph made were ones we would expect him to and he let himself down flapping at corners.

 

carswell won the ball back and made a lot of tackles s he gets my vote.

[pingu]

i thought all the saves randolph made were ones we would expect him to and he let himself down flapping at corners.

 

 

 

 

 

you don't really know too much about football do you? What did Randolph do that let the team down? Did his alleged flapping lead to goals? No. Did his good saves and awareness save us from getting beat 4-0? Yes.

 

Simples

 

 

 

 

 

[steelboy]

you don't really know too much about football do you? What did Randolph do that let the team down? Did his alleged flapping lead to goals? No. Did his good saves and awareness save us from getting beat 4-0? Yes.

 

Simples

 

 

 

 

 

 

getting beat one nil is the same as getting beat 4 nil.

 

randolph was left looking like a dick 3 or 4 times flapping at crosses. by his own high standards not one of his better performances.

[pingu]

getting beat one nil is the same as getting beat 4 nil.

 

randolph was left looking like a dick 3 or 4 times flapping at crosses. by his own high standards not one of his better performances.

 

 

Yes getting beat is getting beat, but there are different ways of getting beat, or winning for that matter.

 

 

A lot of it is to do with a little thing in football called goal difference. Can be quite important, ask Alex Ferguson.

 

 

If the world was set to your logic then it doesn't matter how the 3 possible outcomes of a match are reached. So we might just be as well not going and sitting in to play football manager instead. Maybe if that happened you would give us all peace from the ill informed nonsense you sprout

 

 

[Yabba's Turd]

i thought all the saves randolph made were ones we would expect him to and he let himself down flapping at corners.

 

carswell won the ball back and made a lot of tackles s he gets my vote.

You don't half talk some shite.

[wellman]

Who on earth is it that keeps voting for Tom Hately have they been to the game ?

[Big Trac]

Who on earth is it that keeps voting for Tom Hately have they been to the game ?

 

Hehe. Too true. Absolute 'mare last night.

[Yoshi-1991]

Who on earth is it that keeps voting for Tom Hately have they been to the game ?

 

Tom.

[foghorn]

Randolph with mention for Higinbotham

[StipeIsGod]

_{Randolph, though Carswell has certainly forced his way into what would be my first 11.}

[Suspect Device]

Possibly a sympathy vote for Hately. Having to play behind an imposter every week (who also gets a vote every game).

[Big Stall]

Possibly a sympathy vote for Hately. Having to play behind an imposter every week (who also gets a vote every game).

 

And the guy who votes for the right winger doesn't even go to the games!

[superwell87]

Randolph. Prevented the scoreline from getting worse

[Easy Target]

Possibly a sympathy vote for Hately. Having to play behind an imposter every week (who also gets a vote every game).

 

Agreed.