I'm not Reynolds' biggest fan, but I do think he is probably worthy of a first team place while Hutchison is out injured.
My main gripe, and Frazzle has mentioned it, is how quickly people jump on Craigans back after he makes a mistake similar to the Reynolds (or Ruddy) one last night but there is never the same outcry when Reynolds does it.
People will say it is because of the amount of times Craigan has made mistakes, but he has been around longer and thats bound to happen but I bet if there was a ratio of 'games played/mistakes made 'for both Reynolds and Craigan, they would probably be neck and neck.
As I said, I'm not his biggest fan so I'm probably being a bit harsh on him, but I,personally, would definetly feel more comfortable with a Hutchison/Cragain CB pairing than the one we have just now.