The thing is we have a lot of decent defenders but all have their problem area's..
Craigan - Reads the game well, good experience, wins a lot in the air for his height, BUT too slow, small?, terrible distribution
Reynolds - Excellent young prospect, gives us some much needed pace and has saved us quite a few times with this BUT a bit lightweight, certainly needs dropped/rested if possible as 2 seasons non stop is a lot for a young kid
Malcolm - Did well when came in, provides good aggression and good passing ability BUT way too slow and positioning leaves a lot to be desired at times...
McLean - Tall/good in air (?!), but I am never sure why people appear to rate him SO much, he was never that big a player for us before his injuries so dont know if he will be after, but would certainely be useful to have fit!
If we could mix and match some of these guys qualities we could have a pretty decent central defence, but then again I suppose that is part of being Motherwell and not Man Utd etc. If players had it all they inevitably will be playing above our level, or am I too used to watching our defence?!