wellwell91

Correct they actually made the team worse if that was at all possible

Sorry but up until today was prepared to give him benefit of the doubt BUT how can anyone explain those substitutions today ……… the back 3 were doing fine and never at any time look under pressure The obvious problem was the midfield where Grimshaw was a waste of a jersey McHugh couldn’t pass water and for god sake please please get Tait back to right hand side where he belongs And as for Main he canny even foul people properly and couldn’t score in a barrel of F****y’s So we end up with 4 forwards on ( 3 of whose 1st touch is a pass) and no one to get the ball to them Im afraid I think he has lost the plot and it’s tie for him to GO and GO now

That farce today should be done under Trade Description Act for trying to impersonate a FOOTBALL MATCH !!!!!!!!!!

Yip the priority has got to be St Midden Killie and Accies games As the Tic will be up for this big time and the way they tend to keep the ball and make opposition teams work I would save the legs of Campbell, Turnbull,Main and Johnston for the more important games coming up. Also change of formation 4 - 5 - 1 for me and try to frustrate them anything we get out of this game is a Xmas bonus!!!! Gillespie Mbulu. Aldred Hartley Dunne Grimshaw Bigi Gorrin Rose Frear Bowman Tell Bowman to empty his tank then substitute him for Salmon at about 55 / 60 minutes

Your right … … was speaking to him on Wednesday night and injury making progress but he doubts if he will play this season

Sorry … … … But it’s got to be horses for courses Livii had about 5 or 6 guys who were 6ft+ They play for set pieces so they can fire in free kicks, corners or long throws We play a midfield of midgets !!!! So what do you expect … … they score from a long throw and a corner If ever there was a time to play hoof ball this was it there is no way you can play football on that surface and no way you can run with the ball so the surface took away everything that Bigi and Grimshaw brought to the party last week.

Picked up knee knock against Rangers … … worse than first thought, heard he could be out for up to a month Young Livingston at left back and Tait to right back Lets stop trying to be smart and stop trying to put square pegs in round holes

Samson going to coach the goalkeepers what NOT to do to make them better goalkeepers

Was Thomson not the ref a few years ago when we were beating Aberdeen 1-0 Aberdeen got a penalty’s which was saved (can’t remember keeper) and twat face Thomson made them take it again due to encroachment, how many times have you seen that happen. Needless to say Aberdeen scored with the retake

Your understanding is correct his contract is up in the summer along with that of Barry Maguire not sure about Adam Livingston As I have said on numerous occasions on various threads have watched young Turnbull over last couple of years ( ok got to take into account quality of opposition) but watching this boy there is something about him. He should have been getting game time at the start of the season against the likes of Edinburgh City, Clyde, Stranraer as should Barry Maguire Very similar to young Campbell last year it has taken us till we have just about hit rock bottom before these boys are given a chance. We should be getting his contract extended as a matter of priority along with that of Barry Maguire ( here’s another snippet for you this boy has also got what it takes to kick on in this game if only we give him a CHANCE ) This is where man management comes into play with these boys knowing when to put them in and take them out as there is going to be a period with every young player whe the go off the boil. Think this is the case with young Campbell sine he came into the team last year the boy has hardly had a break from 1st team went away with Scotland in the summer played in all their gams and has also played during the international breaks this season …… to much football !!!! The break he is having at the moment in my mind will do him good and hopefully like yesterday manager manages minutes on the park between Campbell and Turnbull as I have every hope that they will be our midfield for quite a few years to come.

Nether Mbulu, Turnbull or Maguire were in the reserve squad yesterday Livingston only played for 45 minutes Whats the chances of them playing involved tomorrow night?

YES WE DO His name is Barry Maguire But just like David Turnbull ( up until Saturday) Robinson will not give him a chance

David Turnbull display yesterday proved that he has the ability at this level Still only a young lad and he tired after about 65 minutes which should have been anticipated by coaching staff and a plan being in place for substitution That said the time that this boy should have been getting 65 - 70 minutes of game time was during league cup section games and he was nowhere to be seen [ shite forward planning] As far as this 3-5-2 shite goes time for it to be binned …… think Robinson is so intrenched and stubborn that he won’t change it Time for 4-5-1 formation ……… only 1 up top because Main and Bowman between them barely contribute 1 player

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again young Turnbull has all the attributes to make it to the very top IMO he’s got more potential than Alan Campbell Should he be playing every week …… No Should he be getting more game time ……Yes As what happens with a lot of young players Alan Campbell has hit the proverbial brick wall … boy got no rest over the summer as he was away with Scotland and he’s played in every U21 games this season ……… Club should have been more proactive in protecting him ……… but our start to the season and Robinson’s insistence that we play 3 -5-2 has meant that he has played in just about every game. Looking forward to the day when we play Cadden Campbell and Turnbull in midfield …… although think that is a long way off under Robinson

NAIL. HAMMER. HEAD

For me that hits the nail on the head !!!!!!

FFS what can you say about that performance absolute non event as a football match both teams would put you off wanting to go to games Livi were bad but what sort of performance was that from us Donnelly must be one of the worst players to pull on the jersey in the last 20 years But to the main cause for concern OUR shape we played back 3 all season and it is just not working but Robinson is determined to persevere with it. A blind man and his dug can see it’s not working but still he continues with it. We still continue to try and put round pegs in square holes eg. Donnelly and Tait on the left when neither of them are comfortable on their left foot created a complete on balance. I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s his way or no way I cannot believe the seasoned ex pros like Lasley or McManus can sit there and are unable to see what is going on Im sorry but my patience (along with plenty of people around me in POD) is running out with Robinson ……… he’s dug himself into a hole with the formation and seem unwillingly or incapable of changing it. Some of our attempts to pass the ball to our own players today was embarrassing

Change of formation is a must … … we must start by not giving the opposition freebies To that end a back 4 is a must I would then play defensive midfielder in front of them and then a midfield 4 with 1 up front We really have to get back to a solid base to build from

Unless he wakes up and smells the coffee BACK 3 IS JUST NOT WORKING He’s persevered with it all season and we don’t have the players to play that system this season So unless he alters formation this week it will just show that he thinks that it is working ( probably the only one in the ground who does) If that is the case then it is time for him to go

I was there when we beat Stoke on penalty’s after drawing 2-2 in Texaco Cup Keith MacRea saved 2 that night … … got a funny feeling he scored with a penalty as well

Sincerely hope we have a massive sell on clause on him as the only place he’s going is to the Premiership

Could not believe the numbers ……apparently we have 51 signed players on our books So how exactly are our youngsters going to get any game time As I said in earlier post both Turnbull and Maguire are out of contract at end of the season

Don’t think anyone is comparing quality of opposition U20 against that of the 1st team Couple of years ago I watched a young Alan Campbell in the U20 and thought that he had all the attributes to make an impact in the 1st team which he has done once he was given the chance to do so. Also in that team albeit a year younger was David Turnbull and I have taken an interest in his progression ever since. I think that this boy has the ability and attitude to make it to the highest level in the game way beyond Motherwell To my mind he has all the attributes that Campbell brings to the table and a bit more, he can pick a pass and has hit a few screamers from outside the box. This is where I have a problem with Robison … … how do we know if this boy is good enough if he is not given a chance to show what he can do at a higher level. Yes he has been given a couple of outings at the end of last season and to my mind did not look out of place … but we resign Rose, Grimshaw and Gorrin and the boy finds himself way down the pecking order. If anyone is going to the Sligo game I suggest you have a good look a this young boy and see what he could bring to the table IMO he is way beyond his years and if only like Campbell he could just be given a chance who knows where it could lead to.

No he’s bigger than McHugh, Aldred and Hartley He reads the game very well and has a good footballing brain into th bargain thats why he’s playing where he is

Think both Turnbull and Maguire’s contracts are up at the end of the season Club then has decisions to make re contract extensions and will they put pen to paper if no sign of 1st team involvement