Quite a few teams have chosen this route of late.
The new Oldham Athletic crest
Coventry City retro crest
and FC Thun who are shortly moving to a brand new stadium, allowed the fans to choose a new logo for a new era in the club's history.
I like our current crest, I think certain elements just need to be better drawn. Before computer graphics club badges were designed in a traditional manner using conventional freehand and technical drawing skills. Over the years I've designed numerous things using this tried and tested method. Our original badge was designed this way, although I'm pretty certain the finished artwork has long gone! Someone at some point recreated the badge in digital form and without sending you all to sleep certain elements have been poorly translated from the original. An example would be the fir trees on the original 1982 badge which were clearly defined. On some recent versions floating around they have seen better days. I suspect some lazy designer/printer has used "Auto Trace" or "Adobe Streamline" at some point to convert our badge to digital form. This is a quick method used to convert old style graphics to vector, but is no where near as accurate as recreating it by hand in Illustrator, Freehand or Coral Draw.
It seems that now with a little computer graphics knowledge everyone is free to try their hand at design, although without any design training the finished article is usually pretty poor. It all depends what image you want to portray. To compete with the big boys, you need to copy their approach to design detail whenever possible.