All Activity

STV rumour is he's got his jotters

When Robinson left us, he openly admitted he had no idea how to turn things around. When he left St Mirren he had no idea how to turn around their slide. He has no idea how turn around Aberdeen's slide. The game and the players have moved on. He has not.

I honestly think you're at it

I’m never happy to see anyone lose their job but I can always modify that rule for a huge ego’d. narky wee twat who spat the dummy out on so many occasions at every club he’s been at and had to be pulled away (by Craigan) at our last game v Aberdeen as he was hurling abuse at the main stand… ok he got a bit that night… but it shows his mental state that he’s unable to control his anger (Wetherspoons Edinburgh being another example of anger issues) he did well at st Mirren albeit watching that team was eye bleeding and he did ok for us for a period (and got a bit lucky when he HAD to play young players…. When he didn’t want to) until it all past its shelf life but I really do not see him getting another bigger gig up here….. he might get a league 2 or 3 gig down south but he failed down there at that level too. hes not someone I’d be sad to see drift out the game

Stephen Robinson was great for Motherwell at the time and I will always be grateful to him for the 2 Cup Finals and making us feel relevant again in Scottish Football. But the game in this country is moving on. His football/tactics are limited and no longer align with the club philosophy/identity. I think its a shame its not working out for him at Aberdeen, but not a surprise. We would be mental to consider having him back if it ever got to the stage Alfreds job is under threat (which it isnt).

Update for the fortnight to 9 November. Citations are now at 41,685, up from 38,718 at the last update. New pages Biographies: Matt Busby, Graeme Souness, Archie Gemmill and Julie Fleeting each have a page of their own, with sources. Head-to-heads: eleven written comparisons of neighbouring clubs, from Renton and Vale of Leven to Aberdeen and Dundee United, with Queen's Park and Third Lanark, Raith Rovers and East Fife, and St Mirren and Morton among them. The Dundee derby joins the Old Firm and Edinburgh derby pages, and On This Day now covers 354 dates of the year. Every ground now has its own page, and there are three new guides: Defunct clubs, on when and why they went; Family history, for anyone trying to find out whether an ancestor played; and Can you help?, listing the photographs, lost grounds and facts we are still looking for. A film The first international, Scotland against England at Hamilton Crescent on 30 November 1872, now has a short film on its timeline page. It is an AI reconstruction, not archive footage, as no film or photograph of the match exists, and it says so on the page. Every detail we could check was set from the newspaper reports of the day. Women's game All 90 women's club pages have been gone through again and expanded, with 69 pictures added. Grounds East Stirlingshire had two Merchiston Parks, the first until 1906 and its neighbour from 1906 to 1921, with thanks to the club historian. Petershill's page now follows the club from Arrol Park in 1897 to the new ground in Adamswell Street, Kilsyth Rangers were at Garrel Vale Park from 1914 to 1939, and Queen of the South's page notes that Palmerston Park was in the burgh of Maxwelltown until 1929. Crests and photographs 13 more clubs have let us show their crests: Bayside Ladies, Bishopton Women, Buckie Ladies, Danderhall Miners WFC, Edinburgh Caledonia, Glasgow City, Harmony Row, Houston United Ladies, Irvine Meadow XI, Maryhill, Musselburgh Windsor Women, Petershill and Rutherglen Glencairn. Danderhall Miners WFC sent team photographs and East Fife confirmed the credit for theirs. Thanks to all of them. As ever, if you spot something wrong on your club's page, the corrections page is there and I fix things in public. https://scottishfootballhistory.scot

Sounds like Robinson is on the brink of being sacked by Aberdeen. Personally would take him back here if/when we part company with AJ. He had ran his course by the time he left us but when he initially came in he made us competitive and oversaw two cup runs and a(n albeit default) 3rd place finish. Plus he has improved as a manager now and he wouldn’t have Burrows whispering “we’re only a wee team punching way above our weight” in his ear every other day this time around.

What does that even mean? The days of football managers having control and responsibility for absolutely everything to do with the playing side of a football club are long gone. Most clubs (even us!) have a Head/Director of football, a team of analysts, sports scientists, and other individuals who assist them with the day to day running of the football department. Most modern managers are in fact just "Head Coaches". McGlynn is currently doing very well at a club that suits him. But lets not forget that he is coming towards the end of a somewhat ordinary managerial career during which he underwent an epiphany working under Brendan Rogers at Celtic. Before that, he was just another one of many average Scottish managers on the merry-go-round that would have been chased by our fans had he been suggested 10 years ago. Thats not to discredit his current achievements. Merely giving them context. Alfred on the other hand is a very young ambitious coach at the start of his career. Who is to say where he will end up at this stage.

Let him go there then

Oldham beat Sheffield Wednesday in the F.A. Cup. "Oldham manager Micky Mellon had to watch from the sidelines after being sent off for appearing to move his head towards Callum Slattery" Think he's safe this time.

No one scaped a draw at Tannadice.

Mandron helping Stockport into Extra-time against the mighty Cray Wanderers in the FA Cup earlier

Bet you was raging. 🤬

McGlynn's "proper manager" approach earned Falkirk a 0 - 0 at Fir Park. I think he's a great fit at Falkirk, but have no idea how he'd fare at Fir Park. His record at Hearts was poor and at Livi was fair to middling.

You expected us to lose so surely a draw was a positive? And I dont think scraping a draw is accurate

And Dundee Utd have just one defeat in their last eight. Against us. Spooky.

McGlynn is a proper manager, AJ is a coach. Galling to see Falkirk absolutely sweep Hearts aside on their own patch when we are scraping draws at Tannadice and patting ourselves on the back for it. Also, Hearts have just one win in their last eight. Against us.

McGlynn, like Robinson, would be an idiot to go there.

I think Aberdeen will be taking note

I’ll happily hold my hands up if he turns things around and gives us a good season, but I’m not going to pretend to be his biggest fan in the meantime. That doesn’t mean I don’t get behind the team and support them every week.

Leave all the tic talk to kerrydale street.😂

Fair comment, will the "AJ out " supporters do the same then and realise that he is going nowhere, no clocks ticking etc and get back behind him and the team. Or does the agenda not suit that approach.

Agree pal, I really like Johnny k but amount of injuries means we have never seen his full potential

Maybe. Maybe not. Too many intangibles that make players and managers a good fit even from year to year at the same club.

If only we were clinical in front of goal. Mind you we were saying that last season.