All Activity

I liked his goal at Tannadice where he sat down the defender then celebrated by jumping over him before he got up.

That's my biggest gripe, and I have many when it comes to VAR. If they stick with it, let the ref make the call. Give VAR 20 or 30 seconds to review if needed. Can't tell? Then it wasn't clear and obvious, so move on.

Still one of my favourites, but agree 100% it wasn't exactly accurate on the colours.

More on Jordan McGhee from the Dundee Courier. https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/sport/football/dundee-fc/5250602/jordan-mcghee-dundee-departure-confirmed/

Wee Al comes back then we mean business!Be a different player if he came back to us if he or his agent had any sense they would be banging our door take a wage cut and be where he is appreciated and loved. Still young enough to have a good few years with us and get a decent move it he wants to move. Halliday,Slattery and Campbell offt that's a midfield to get ma baws rattling!

Correct when it came in it was to ensure "clear and obvious" errors were corrected. If it takes them over 2 mins to arrive at a decision its not clear and obvious.

If we bin VAR we will have 20 errors in a game called wrong rather than 2 or 3. Whether folk like it or not VAR enables the correct decision to be called in 90% of occasions. However it takes far too long to arrive at the decisions. I would strictly enforce clear and obvious error. If a decision cant be called in 2 mins the onfield decision stands. Fans waiting 3/4/5/6 mins for a decision to be called is ridiculous. I would also adopt the English automated tech for offside decisions rather than the cheapo version we have in Scotland. In England they just do not have the carry on we have looking at offside goals.

Late 70s and early 80s our strip was more Lemon than Amber. The Adidas strip we wore when we ran away with the 1st division title was popular at the time but looking back it was actually quite hideous.

I liked this kit but with claret shorts

JTs against Aberdeen was my favourite.

Do you agree? What was your goal of the season?

I think it’s the best thing that ever happened to improve the modern game … said no one ever !

Just need a malfunction of the technology and both teams agreeing to play without. Might look a bit suspicious when it happens at every ground every week, but worth a try,

Bring him home , can’t see Halliday lasting the full season . Having Campbell back would give us a bit more steel

Kilmarnock home attendance v the OF are almost identical to ours so they didn't boost their average attendance any more than ours. St Johnstone home attendances v the OF were less than ours.

They'll never get rid of it, they've fucked it up by bringing it in but there is no going back unfortunately

Get it in the bin. That was my response to the survey.

It is not being used properly.......but is only ever an issue when it affects the old squirm

It’s ruining football. It is far too jobsworth-like and rather than intervening to correct clear and obvious errors by onfield officials it is too often going back to earlier phases of play to almost forensic examine everything that happens in the build up to goals/penalties to find even the most minuscule infringement. Get rid ASAP

I was happy to share my views in great detail. tl;dr ditch it

No survey or debate required, VAR needs binned ASAP its ruining the game, especially the pound shop version we have in Scotland and the incompetent clowns running it.

For those who aren't in the Well Society or who didn't see the email, the following was sent out today: As the first top-flight football club in the UK to be owned by its supporters, Motherwell Football Club, through the Well Society, has a duty to ensure that the views of our fans are properly represented on important matters within the game. Growing concerns around VAR Over recent months, concerns have been growing among fans, players and staff across the country regarding the impact VAR is having on the rhythm of matches, the atmosphere in stadiums and trust in refereeing decisions. In addition to these concerns, it is important to note that VAR currently costs each club a six-figure sum every season. A significant outlay that further underlines the need for a proper debate about its future. Listening to our members and shaping the future In light of this, the Well Society has committed to starting a process of listening and engaging with our members and the wider Motherwell support. Our aim is to gain a clearer understanding of supporters’ views on VAR and to consider whether the Society should take a position in favour of change or call for its removal from Scottish football altogether. This marks the beginning of a wider effort to build connections with other supporter groups and to explore the potential for positive, fan-led action. You can share your view by completing the survey available here between now and Monday 2nd June at noon.

Interesting that there is more-or less a full line up out of the top 11...... Oxborough O'Donnell Kaleta Casey Wilson Sparrow Slattery Miller Halliday Maswanhise Watt I know...slow work day...

You honestly wonder what some fans expect. This season was a very 'average' season but the thing these days is that everything has to be 'the worst ever' or 'the best ever'.

Career has gone down a major dip but I kind of agree. He had a kind of off season with us before he left and you'd still kind of feel he was still better than a lot of the guys we've had there.....or at least not worse but with more potential. Might not be possible due to wages and he might not want to come back here at this stage in his career but I'd be inclined to take the risk if it was possible. Of course you'd need to sit down and work out what kind of shape you want and where he fits in and that's where the manager would come in.