Leaderboard

I wasn't able to tune in yesterday so missed the play by play. BUT this is quite a simple game really. The manager and many on here are going on about the chalked off goal and how that might have changed the game. Surely it's simply that neither the players nor the manager understood that that was just how that incident played out and we just had to keep WORKING away rather than being downhearted. Even if that goal had been allowed Hibs still scored three without reply. It seems we didn't dig down deeper than they did, so we need not keep on about the referee, even if he got that one decision absolutely wrong. The two keys for any team are motivation (the manager's job) and commitment (the players job), and clearly neither showed up yesterday.

McGinley is never a full back, he’s the best fit for filling in at the moment. The first has been explained further up, both he and Gallagher move one across to cover the gaping hole left by Mugabi... again. Damned if they do, damned if they don’t and the ball is dropped centrally. Whilst caught in possession for our 3rd, regardless if the game is gone at that point, Mark O’Hara can’t escape criticism for another non attempt at protecting the back four - the primary role of holding midfielders.

Not so sure - its a bit harsh blaming him for the first. Boyle was his man, but he went to put pressure on Nisbet (i think it was?) who looked like he was about to have a free header. 3rd goal, yeah, brutal but like you say game was done. Personally I believe there's a player in there. Have never been a fan of robbo's back 3 lineups, but I think its needed right now - O'hara, dec and mugabi.