Yorkyred

It’s not that long ago that Championship clubs down south were looking at him by all accounts. Sounds like he is a typical Robinson signing, a rough diamond with plenty of potential. Of course Robinson will be getting linked with the Hearts job now if Stendel is on his way.

I think we’ve made quite a positive start transfer wise given where many clubs find themselves just now, looks to be a good signing to me.

No way would we be offering a 3 year deal plus 50k, that’s nonsense.

I’ve been thinking the same thing, no doubt we have lost out along with everyone else, but I still believe we are probably in better health than many others.

Personally I would have liked to see him stay, maybe he wanted more starts which is fair enough.

Yep, very easy to predict before he even put a Rangers shirt on.

Hastie will obviously just be loaned out again, he’s probably going to be moving around for a while until Rangers eventually let him go.

We don’t appear to be a club that’s willing to burst the bank for any player these days. I doubt any of the new signings are going to be on big money and I don’t see that changing. The days of a motherwell signing well known names seem to be over.

Personally I don’t see Dunne staying, he’s only been offered a short term contract to prove his fitness and I think there has to be real doubts he’s going to be able to even do that. Lamie will be a good back up for Carroll when needed in my view with him playing at centre half alongside Gallagher rather than Donnelly.

Looks like a solid signing, experience at the level and Robinson clearly rates him so not so much one of his punts.

Amazing watching highlights of the Cup finals and just how few players are left. Just two years ago and three players still with us from the starting eleven.

Probably more acceptable to many than Campbell. He has always divided opinion within the fanbase.

I would not rule it out, he will have his admirers for sure. Not the most technically gifted but as you state he does have other qualities.

Gallagher, superb signing.

But you simply don’t know, given you have have never replied to posters asking if you have seen him play you have jumped to a negative conclusion simply based on the manager being his father. Surely you can see how unfair that is.

I like it.

It’s just very unfair, basically it’s saying you can’t be good enough just because your dad is the manager. There have been plenty of top class players who’s father have been managers, you can’t write them off just because they are both at the same club.

You would hope they remember he gave a lot to the club and actually wanted to stay.

And nice to see all the good wishes on his twitter feed, it’s amazing how many players have nothing but good things to say about the club. I guess it’s that same feeling that Stephen and I had when we started supporting Motherwell, not the biggest, or the most successful, but a club with something special about it.

Livi fans seem to think he must have something else already lined up, surprised and disappointed he left. I thought he looked to have improved with them after leaving Thistle but for me I don’t think he’s what we need and can’t say I’m a massive fan.

Personally I have never seen him play so can only trust that those with more knowledge than myself have acted in the best interest of the club.

What if he actually deserves a contract simply because he’s done well enough to earn one ?

No real arguments with any of the released players, Hartley needs a change but will do a job for someone else, he’s just not a good fit for the way we play now and he will be on a good wedge. I’ve always liked Tait but understand he’s just not getting enough game time

To be fair that game was a complete cluster, you could have released half the first team if you only judged them on that performance. We were all over the place.

Very happy to see that Tony Watt has signed a contract for next season.