All Activity
- Past hour
-
Our points tally and run of results speaks for itself. The only genuine positive I could take from yesterday was the excellently worked set-piece goal.
-
Anyone else notice last night the 4th official had 13 mins added time on board then changed it to 3 once rangers scored! š¤Ŗ
-
I understand your position and you are entitled to your opinion. But you only highlight the negatives whilst totally ignoring any positives. Fine if you dont see any, but, in my opinion at least, there have been improvements. Our defending for one has improved significantly in the last few weeks. Its not long since folk on here werent having Paulsen as a keeper, yet he nearly wins us a point last night and its dismissed. Moorman and JGR were much better last night and thru their bodies on the line making blocks and closing attackers down, all of which was missing weeks ago, yet thats dismissed as its their job. Our press still isnt perfect and causes us problems at times, but for 50-60 minutes last night it WAS much better. We did win balls back in midfield which allowed us to break more quickly. Ok we didnt take advantage of it, but it was an improvement. Oscar and Hodge are screening the centre of the pitch much better and we arent allowing so many free shots at our goal from central areas. Perfect, no, but better, definitely. We only lost 2 goals last night, both from set pieces against a much bigger team physically. That takes commitment and effort which seems to be there in abundance despite a suggested lack of quality. Our biggest problem right now is we dont have an out ball without Said. SPH does a lot of running and no one can fault his effort, but he doesnt win nearly enough ball to get us up the park. (Not than Don Robertson helped him last night). Hendry looked an upgrade when he came on, which surprised me, but could help us unlock the forward area if he can stay fit and get gametime. Another positive. We do need to figure out what to do with our midfield as Oscar, Fadinger, Hodge and Lowry doesnt seem to go in our current set up, but all have something to offer. Maswanhise as well is a conundrum as we are not getting anywhere near the best out of him. Id love to see more movement, better rotations and more possession of the ball, but without seeing what is happening in training, Ive no idea if that is on Alfred or the players. In short, we are a long way from where I would want us to be, and where I hoped we would be, but it doesnt look like a lost cause. Of course its a results driven business and if we do end up getting detached at the bottom after the next 5 games then I may have to review my opinion and accept time is up. But we are not there yet.
-
We have had Scottish managers most of my lifetime - 57 years. We have never had any real sustained success. Currently, of the options available, I dont see anyone who we could afford that would develop us as a club. There is a reason that Scottish clubs dont do well in Europe. Jens identified it right away when he came in. Now, Im not saying Alfred will 100% work out and will go the distance. He may not. But the clubs philosophy and identity now is to play possession based, attacking, entertaining football. We arent suddenly going to about turn and employ a "McInnes Type" manager. Firstly, we couldnt get someone of his calibre, so you are looking at "McInnes Lite" which was effectively Robinson or Kettlewell. That always runs its course eventually. McGlynn, I would love to have. But he isnt leaving Falkirk for us and he isnt a "McInnes Type" anyway, since his year under Rodgers. Like it or lump it, we are stuck with Alfred and even if he does get canned we will go after someone with a similar CV. If a young Scottish Coach with the same characteristics comes through in the meantime we might go Scottish again, but I wouldnt hold my breath on that.
- Today
-
My thoughts..... Started terrible, had a real fear first 10 we were on a scudding Losing that goal so early is brutal. Cany defend a corner Settled into the game & looked decent when we had the ball in their half. They did cut through us with ease though Keeper outstanding & some great assistance from defenders throwing themselves at shots. Even before Said went off he shat out of two tackles that are food & drink to him. I think he was already struggling Not an RCC fan but he did well. No idea why he was subbed Throwing on thor at 1-1 was crazy if we were going to do nothing to change shape & try to win. Another defender or midfielder to keep the point was the play 1-1 would have flattered us but iv seen us play better &get fuck all. That was an opportunity lastnight. Cany complain, despite our defending & keeper heroics 1-2 is fair. 6 rangers players went to celebrate with the fans. Only 1yellowcard??? Ref was so inconsistant last night (against both teams) While there wasnt (1000's doing a pitch invasion there was a couple of rangers fans who did come on) just clearing that up since a member of the kirk has decided they are hollier than thow........
-
Correct.
-
If aimlessly knocking it about at the back before aimlessly launching it up the park is our style of play, then weāre screwed. Yes, it allows the manager to claim that weāve retained the possession-based approach of JBA, but only in principle, certainly not in application. Itās wasteful crap. And thatās before even considering the complete lack of identifiable structure, which leaves us utterly incapable of winning second balls. I could go on, but thereās little point. If it werenāt for an outstanding performance from Paulsen and some poor finishing from Rangers, weād have been absolutely pumped yesterday. Weāre nothing more than a poorly coached side, and this manager is taking the team and the club backwards.
-
Agree 100%
-
Glad to read your posts in among the many negative ones. Our first 20 mins were a disaster but after that we competed much better and had a couple of good spells but I think we tired the last 10 mins. Early posession was about 25/75 with final stats 40/60. Priestman was knackered the last 10 mins along with Longelo taking a knock and tiring. totally agree that some players can and need to do better and the manager has room to improve but I donāt think we are as bad as made out to be by a lot of people. Preistman will continue to get fitter and better and I think him, Faddy and Lowrie in midfield will see our passing and posession improve. I think we have improved the defense a good bit but the one major area we desperately need to improve on is scoring. Short term we have to hope one or more of our forwards suddenly start scoring. A bit more luck on the injury front would help as well. Still a long way to go but I think we are good enough to start climbing up the table.
-
I think Hodge has been fine so far, does a lot of the dirty work and I think him and priestman could be a good combination in front of the defence. Lowry once fit a defo starter so be interesting how midfield sets up. And yip.....we lost almost £7,000,000 worth of midfield plus slattery. Was always going to be tough without them
-
Okay then, McInnes it is. My overall point relating to us as a club though that when we are looking for our next manager, whenever that may be, looking closer to home might be more beneficial to us. Weāre currently on our third foreign manager in a row which is new territory for us given that our previous non British manager before Wimmer was Harri Kampman way back before the turn of the millennium. Of the latest three one in particular stands out because he did an outstanding job in a short space of team and completely changed the way we play football. It was a joy to watch at times. Before him Wimmer was only really passing through and never felt like he would hang about for long and AJ isnāt long in the door but early signs arenāt looking too clever. At this point we have a manager and arenāt looking for a new one as far as I or anyone is aware but when the time comes I would like to see a steadier hand on the rudder, if you pardon the cliche.
-
He's tidy, I'm just not convinced yet, spoiled by Watt and Just probably
-
Paulsen by a country mile! Moorman was decent again. Very unlucky with the deflection. Hendry surprised me with some very nice touches and passages of play when he came on. Thought Cookie had his best game for a long time. Was sorry to see him go off.
-
Or " **??*" Mjc
-
It suggests a certain deference which is of course dependent on the context. But McInnes isnt hard to type.
-
Hodge was our MOTM against United away. I agree that if Lowry is fit, he should probably be the makeweight as the others usually offer more. But I still think he is a tidy player.
-
What it does matter what I call them? You know who I am talking about whether I say Del, McInnes or āThe Right Honourable Lord McInnes of Kinning Parkā It was the same with āYogiā Hughes āBig Mixuā Paatelainen and āAngeā Postecolglou.
-
Priestman - Fadinger - Lowry I wouldn't have Hodge anywhere near the midfield, been hoping for something from him
-
JT puts in a lot of work running. My issue with him is that he rarely impacts the ball. He gets into the right positions, but never presses or tackles his man. Never blocks a cross and even more frustratingly regularly doesnt anticipate passes or crosses that come in his direction meaning he rarely gets away a first time shot. In his defence though, he is always on the shoulder of the last defender wauting for the ball over the top that never comes! That doesnt seem to be a thing for us this season.
-
Huge game. Real 6 pointer. Win and we can continue to look up. Lose, and we are really back in the shit and the pressure will start to mount on Alfred and the team again. We really need this one. Especially given how poor they were yesterday at home v United.
-
Would make sense as I really cant believe JT lasted 90 mins. Certainly no lack of effort but is contributing hardly anything. Transformation in him from last season is unbelievable
-
Aye but you dont call the others Elvis, John, or Stevie ad nauseam......
-
I mentioned them to illustrate a point, just like I mentioned McGlynn/Falkirk and Pressley/Dundee and Clarke/Scotland. And that point being that having a solid homegrown manager who knows the Scottish game and the league sometimes is better than a foreign āprojectā type manager.
-
Dont know for sure. But I agree he was playing well and just before he got subbed he wasnt moving freely and that continued as he walked down the touchline. Hopefully it was just a minor strain and a precaution.
-
With respect Dave, Im not sure that is true. We still play out from the back. We still play a possession based game. But we do get it forward quicker at times and put in a lot more cross balls than we used to. We also lost Ward, who was fantastic with the ball at his feet, and Watt who was the best midfielder in the country for me last year. Paulsen is a better shotstopper than Ward, but his distribution is nowhere near as good. As for Watt, he AND Just are almost impossible to replace on our budget. So, I dont think we were ever going to be able to replicate last seasons style with a different manager. But if you look at our stats (I know they arent always a true indicator) our passing and possession are still top 3 in the division. Our xG is pretty good too. Someone who could put the ball in the net regularly would improve our position markedly and take a lot of pressure off the defence. Obviously that is a failure in the recruitment side of things and needs fixed and Im sure there are many things Alfred could/should do better. I get that we are in a precarious position right now, but I dont feel as depressed and hopeless as as I did in the last months of Alexander or Kettlewell, despite my wee wobble after the Celtic game!