Kmcalpin

Only one candidate for me and thats Gillespie. He didn't get the protection to which he was entitled but still looked comfortable and saved the penalty.

Time wasting is very rarely taken into account. All I look for is consistency. Still, more important issues to focus on today.

Where did the 4 added on minutes come from? Mr Wright's watch?

Was that a Monday evening 2-0 defeat during Craig Brown's reign? If so, I remember it well. The game should have been called off by the Police because the car park was a death trap. A foot of ice/freezing water to wade through to get to the turnstiles. Compare that to the effoprt we go through at Fir Park these days. As if a long journey back down the A9 after a defeat wasn't bad enough, the road was icy and there was freezing fog. My worst ever car journey.

You're saying that Scottish football is garbage or rubbish (in UK english? If so, what are you comparing it with? For some years now fans' general expectations have become more and more unrealistic. When I say that I'm not referring to one teams ups and downs.

Thats my question too.

Irrespective of who we would prefer for our selections will Peter Hartley be fit? Apparently he has/had a dead leg.

Andy Rose has had limited impact this season, in part due to injury and maybe others like Bigi, Turnbull and Gorrin coming through. Perhaps too it was part of the masterplan to gradually phase him out, in the knowledge that he would only be with us until Hogmanay - who knows. At any rate the midfield dynamic is already changing and there's no-one amongst the current senior players who can replicate that role. Rose reminds me very much of a young Keith Lasley but with more athleticism, but less grit. Not in any way showy, but hovers around to cover up for other more gung ho colleagues' errors. My overall view of his time with us is that whilst he never set the heather on fire he did a passable job, most of it off the ball. Not our worst signing by any means but far from our best. Still, it gives Robbo some time and money (he must have known about Rose's move months ago) to plan for a new player in the upcoming window.

I don't know but if he is rested it would be a nice gesture by Vancouver to pay his wages intil 1 January.

Apologies Andy, my comment was partly tongue in cheek and before the news about Andy Rose was confirmed. At every turn we broadcast the message that we're totally skint (unlike our close rivals). I accept that might be deliberate to dampen dreams of healthy warchests from other clubs. My thinking was that if we were totally skint and no-one was shipped out next month ie the worst case scenario, then if Jake Hastie were to return we couldn't even afford his wages (currently being paid by Alloa presumably). That won't now happen as Andy Rose is leaving next month, although its unclear if any fee, however nominal, will be involved. At the very least a wage will be freed up. I'm ambivalent about him going, although I'd rather we lost a few others first. We are reasonably well off for central midfielders and need to strengthen in other areas first. Centre Back; left sided wide midfielder; creative midfielder and striker. Still now that we know for certain Rose is departing it will free up some cash - maybe to allow us to bring Hastie back .

Steady on Weeyin. Pittodrie and Tannadice really take some beating. Tannadice is the only stadium you need to wear long johns in July.

So, as things stand, Andy Rose may move on next month and Falkirk have made it widely known that they're keen on taking Ross MacLean. If our budget permits, Jake Hastie may return.

Yes of course, but not all will. There are a whole range of factors which might influence an individual's decision on when to move or if indeed to move at all. As Fizoxy says, "Many young players know that it makes more footballing sense to get regular playing time, build a reputation, and reap the rewards of a bigger move a few years later, and actually playing games is why most got into the profession in the first place." Most young players will want to move up in the game and I get that, but timing is also crucial. Some do want to establish themselves first, earn a good reputation and then move on and up.

There are agents and agents as the powers that be at Fir Park will tell you. Some are honourable and conduct themselves as you say. Others are ruthless and don't care about their clients; they simply want their dosh. As far as careers go not everyone is money oriented and desperate to become the next CEO by the time they're 23. In some cases a move for more money might be premature or simply not be right. I've seen colleagues turn down far better paid positions because they didn't like the company, their methods or their personnel. Money is important yes, but its certainly not the end all and be all.

Our fans wouldn't like his brand of football or his reluctance to use bring young players on . He has done very well at St Johnstone and built solid teams. Not great to watch, not exciting but they're competitive, consistent, physical, streetwise, experienced and don't make many mistakes. He likes players with a combative and abrasive attitude like your Murray Davidsons, Liam Craigs and Paul Patons. Not making mistakes is his trademark. In our league that will guarantee you a mid table slot. He's not great at bringing young players on. For some years now St Johnstone have paid higher wages than us (not by a huge amount) despite having smaller crowds. I'd like to know how they balance the books.

Just watched the TV highlights and the time and space the Hearts player was given to cross the ball into our box for their goal was criminal. He was allowed to pick his spot. That put our defence under unnecessary pressure. We're not good at closing teams down outside our penalty area.

It means leaving his post but continuing to be paid and continuing to carry out parts of his job.

As Shaka says above we are in our wee group of 4 teams at the bottom until the end of the season. That doesn't mean that we won't improve when injured players return or we have a good January window. I'm confident though we have enough to finish in 9th or 10th place. If we can beat those teams below us anything we take from sides above us will be a bonus. However we should go out to win every game.

Don't get me wrong Iain, the team should go all out to win these games and they have to believe but its just that I have low expectations this week and next. Just now I have little confidence that the team won't make a crucial error against better sides whilst the oppostion makes none. There's little in these games but just enough to deny us a point, as we've seen often this campaign so far.

The support seems to be split about David Turnbull. FWIW my view is that he should sign a year's deal or 2 years at the most, with us before moving on. He's got a lot to learn yet but he doesn't want to end up in Chris Cadden's position. He should be aware though that his agent's view will be heavily influenced by the prospect of a nice fat fee. That said I do understand those fans who are "advising" him to jump to a bigger club.

Calm down folks. Not a game we were ever likely to take anything from (same again next week and at Parkhed) but both Accies and St Mirren got beaten (Saints also dropped a goal on us). Our big games come at the end of the month.

There are "roasters" in all 3 home stands, probably least in the POD Stand and most in the East. Its down to capacity & demographics.

Absolutely. Jersey pulling goes on week in week out and is rarely punished. Danny Johnson was blatantly pulled to the ground last Saturday at Livingston in the box and no foul was given. You just need to look at post match pictures to see the amount of jersey pulling that goes on. Its a foul!

My thoughts exactly. There is a huge gap between youth football and first team football but you'd think that fitness wouldn't and shouldn't be one of them. Surely thats down to the sports science team? If a player is being given all the advice and help necessay from the managerial staff and ignoring it then thats a different matter; but thats not the case here. Puzzling.

Maybe that was a factor in his selection last night.