MOTM Hearts 29-Nov-2025

[weeyin]

Inevitable 0 - 0.

Take your pick...

[texanwellfan]

Went for Walsh. Thought he strolled through the game. 

[grumpy]

A toss up between McGinn and Welsh for me. Went with the captain.

[fizoxy]

Welsh was excellent, but Elliot Watt ran the game for us.  

[wellup83]

This is getting more and more difficult with each passing week. No failures on the pitch at all again but Welsh is an absolute brick wall. Need to get him signed if possible.

[Spiderpig]

Welsh for me, he never put a foot wrong all game, an excellent performance.

[mio]

McGinn was phenomenal today, played at a level I didn’t think he was capable of. He got my vote but Welsh was outstanding as well. 
to be fair, they all put in a tremendous shift, a few were a bit off if I thought, longello, slattery but they worked their ar5es off and I can’t complain too much.

[Lobey_Dosser]

Welsh for me, strolled it. 

[texanwellfan]

Honorable mention for Hendry for the goal line clearance. 

[2/6 tae get in]

Also thought McGinn or Welsh . First instinct was McGinn so voted for him.

[Yabba's Turd]

3 hours ago, wellup83 said:

 Need to get him signed if possible.

Would be Dreamland if we could, I think he has much higher ambition than premiership title also rans

[weeyin]

I'd be happy (but surprised) if we can keep Welsh until the end of the season.

It's a double edged sword taking good players on loan. We benefit in the short term, but if they do well, they often get re-called by their parent club in the first window.

[sinjy]

0-0 A clean sheet and keeper really didn't have a save. So it has to be a defender. Toss up between Welsh and McGinn. Went for McGinn.

[texanwellfan]

5 minutes ago, sinjy said:

0-0 A clean sheet and keeper really didn't have a save. So it has to be a defender. Toss up between Welsh and McGinn. Went for McGinn.

Keeper has had zero saves against Hearts and Hibs, although our players have cleared two off the line

[grizzlyg]

Welsh outstanding 

[joewarkfanclub]

Thought Just had a really good game and had he finished that chance he would have been my pick.

However, Stephen Welsh was absolutely outstanding. Both defensively and bringing it out from the back.

We really need to try and get him on a PCA in January.

[couttsy]

Great performances from McGinn, Watt and Fadinger but it has to be Welsh for me. 

[wellfan]

I gave it to Just because he’s such an intelligent player and genuinely a joy to watch. That said, I could easily have given it to Welsh for the stability he brings to the system and the quality he shows playing out from the back. Our number one priority should be trying to sign him permanently or bringing in someone similar.

[Welly Machine]

A good performance in general but thought Welsh completely strolled it. Hope we can keep him beyond January.

Watt, Just and McGinn also contenders.

[weeyin]

5 hours ago, wellfan said:

I gave it to Just because he’s such an intelligent player and genuinely a joy to watch. That said, I could easily have given it to Welsh for the stability he brings to the system and the quality he shows playing out from the back. Our number one priority should be trying to sign him permanently or bringing in someone similar.

 

I'm sure it's Welsh's ability to play from the back that annoys old school defenders like Craigan into criticizing our style of play.