No, not examples of a smaller club than Motherwell, I said "other smaller clubs," as in clubs like Motherwell, who are smaller than many in their division.
Well, context is a significant factor here. Although Brighton might be willing to invest £30 million in a player, they find themselves in direct competition with teams capable of spending upwards of £80 million on a single player. Brighton's wage bill ranks 14th among the 20 teams in the league, providing a clear perspective on the circumstantial challenges they face.
Smaller clubs like Brighton succeed not because of their financial prowess but due to their well-structured systems and unique approaches. Examples of this include:
Data Analytics and Scouting:
Effective use of data analytics in scouting helps identify players with specific attributes that align with the team's playing style.
Brighton has been known for employing a data-driven approach, using analytics to identify players who can contribute significantly to the team.
On this point, I feel we've been really poor. I mean, the data analytics were right there for Theo Bair. It didn't take an advanced system to work out how he's likely to perform. I said before a ball was kicked that if he gets regular starts for us we can likely expect maybe 4 goals. Someone dropped the ball big-time on that signing. The fact he was given a 2-year deal was borderline criminal.
Youth Development:
Developing a strong youth academy can be a cost-effective way to produce talented players who can contribute to the first team or be sold for a profit.
Brighton's commitment to youth development can be seen in their efforts to nurture talent from a young age.
Our clubs management of our youth department hasn't been the best. We've seen a lot of players leave when they could have been approached earlier about signing a new deal and so on. That's not to say that every young player will want to sign a deal, but I feel we've missed the boat on a few of our players due to us not being on top of things and allowing other clubs to swoop in and take advantage.
Strategic Managerial Appointments:
Appointing managers with a proven track record of success in developing teams and getting the best out of players.
Stability in coaching staff can contribute to long-term success by providing continuity and a consistent playing style.
Again, this is a criteria we should be looking at from a lower level. Which managers are doing a good job in the lower reaches of the English, Welsh, or Irish leagues? Who has shown that they can develop a team, improve players, and work with youth?
An important facet of this section is that the manager needs a competent recruitment and analytics team working with him. Do we have that? I'm not so sure. Which is why I'm not 100% sure that the manager is entirely to blame.
Team Cohesion and Tactical Consistency:
Building a cohesive team with a strong sense of identity and a consistent playing style can lead to better on-field performance.
Maintaining tactical consistency, even with changes in personnel, helps players adapt quickly and enhances team performance.
This is something that is a hallmark of Brighton's success, and it really isn't down to finance. They were linked with all manner of different, well-known coaches when Potter left, but they brought in De Zerbi. Their Chief Exec actually said the main reason for his appointment was that he was a "cultural and technical" fit. Sure, he's different in some ways but has a similar philosophy in most areas, which means he doesn't need to completely tear up the squad and start again to fit his own style.
Anyway, a lengthy post, but I think it's important to stress that we can't (and shouldn't) just shrug our shoulders and say "Well, we signed Bair and Obika because we can only afford £20 and a Curly Wurly."
There are a lot of areas we could be better in that don't require tons of money. We can, with some proper oversight, become one of the clubs that catch tomorrow's much sought-after analytics, strategic and tactical geniuses before they hit the radar of bigger clubs. Same with youth players and the management team we have at that level.