texanwellfan

Probably a good call. Seddon to step up if Wilson tires or gets hurt or on a yellow.

Baller has done ok but I think Gordon and Casey are the first choices and so I’d have Balmer on the bench.

For the Tuesday game or both games?

I’m not sure we have created any real chances for him to be judged on so far

I’m pretty much resigned to us producing performances like that now and again but it doesn’t make it any easier to take when it happens. So that’s about 2 in 12 and if we can keep it at that ratio or better we should still do pretty well. Need to bounce back against Hibs next week. Probably not happening but I’d be looking for a more aggressive line up from the start. I’d replace Halliday whose been more invisible than bad.

Well that was shite from start to finish

WTf

Bad day all round from line up, tactics and performances

Totally disorganized Terrible day. Roll on next game

How many forwards we have on now and looking just as toothless. Basically county pressuring us now.

so much for that plan

As illustrated very aptly by this game

Fairly dismal first half. Stam looks comfortable getting decent balls but just no support. As a team we look comfortable for the most part but need more attacking. Grizzly Might be right about getting Manwanise on.

No threat up front. 38 mins and no shots on target that I can remember

No commentary again?

When is Vale projected to start playing again?

If Miller is good enough to play for the national team he should be selected. Many players have started their full international careers as teenagers. So do we regard Miller as good for an 18 year old or good in comparison to other players? I sometimes wonder if we actually do our young players a disservice by treating them with kid gloves due to their age.

Some very civil posts. Am I on an alternate steelmen in line? 😂 No trying to convince each other that your viewpoint is correct. Just sharing opinions on individual perceptions of SK and his time here. I find it quite interesting seeing how each person views his performance and interested to see if people’s assessments will change/align as we go through the season and beyond and also to see if SK changes/learns as he progresses.

He will decide where he goes so we can only hope that he gets better offers from outwith Scotland.

Well first game at Fir Park was a dour 0-0 tie

We have a run of about 6 games ahead of us that are winnable if we play well, although for some them of a draw would not be a bad result. Since we have already won 2 league games in a row the chances of us achieving 8 wins in a row are slim and probably the chance of us going 8 in a row undefeated are less than 50/50. So all we can do is focus on one game at a time and we’ll see how things end up. COYW

I think the law talks about natural position and that natural position can be different depending on what the player is doing. I don’t know how they coach the refs on determining the correct call nowadays but in my mind first two questions should be 1. did he deliberately touch the ball with his hand/arm? 2. did he deliberately make himself bigger? if the answer to either of those questions is yes then the player should be penalized and be at least yellow carded. Red card for saving it being a goal. No question regarding proximity to where the ball was played or if it ricocheted as that comes under consideration in the questions. That covers the defensive end at the attacking end it’s much more clear cut 1. did the scorer (deliberately or accidentally) touch the ball with his hand/arm before the ball went over the line? if the answer is yes then goal is disallowed. However that then leads us onto the question of punishment. I think the following should apply 1. accidental. No card 2. Deliberate scoring goal red card (balances red card for a defender saving a goal). deliberate controlling ball yellow card I think that leaves one point to be resolved discussed. The attacker will have goal disallowed even for accidental hand ball so if a defender stops the ball going into the net with accidental hand ball should a goal be awarded? Penalty? doesn’t seem like there is 100% way to guarantee the same decision for every situation but surely it can be much more consistent than it is now. I don’t think it should have been penalty against Halliday. To support my impartiality, I don’t think Lennon millers goal should have been awarded earlier in the season when the ball ricocheted around and clearly hit his arm before he scored. So much for my earlier statement above “at the attacking end it’s much more clear cut” 😂

If the ref gives a PK and he disallows the goal, surely both players should have got yellow cards but neither did.

I’m not sure he deliberately used his hand/arm. I think he tried to header it but totally mistimed it and it went in via his arm. However, regarding the jist of your argument, I’d agree. edit: just looked at highlights. It was deliberate. A volleyball-esque move to direct the ball into the goal. Did he even get a yellow??

SK doesn’t have a monopoly on signing bad players. It’s been going on for a long time.