Aye it's a fair point mate. Just feel that if both were to fulfil their potential, Reynolds would be the more valuable asset. Terribly disappointed with him this season however.
If I were McGhee, I'd let the two of them sign off for summer just now and come back fresh for the pre-season. Reynolds in particular has had little time off in the last 2 years.
With regards strikers, if we are going down the Sutton route, then get some quality down the wings in a 442 and Sutton wont be far off 15 a season.