Jump to content

Motherwell v Rangers 21/11/2026


SteelmaninOZ
 Share

Recommended Posts

It’s always interesting how we can watch the same game and come to different conclusions. 
I was there so judging in the moment rather than from tv angles or replays.  
Charles- Cook had a good game and was definitely disrupting their midfield and making plays for us. 
To me SP-H was actually doing a half decent job closing them down, some decent hold up play, and challenging for balls lofted vaguely in his direction. What he didn’t always be is support alongside but there were a few good moments. 
Poulsen, JGR and MM don’t have the benefit of a Watt or any central midfield player to build triangles from - that’s tactics rather their ability. They did a pretty good basic defensive job with tackles and blocks.  
Hodge is by no means shit. Genuinely how anyone could watch that game and think that is peculiar.  
JT also put in a power of work which he needed to as Sparrow didn’t play well. 
All of them were up against a more than decent Rangers side who were actually playing football.

i can’t say that we shouldn’t have lost that game given the amount of chances they created but we were ultimately unlucky it was a deflects goal that won it.  There’s plenty of times I don’t think we’ve got the result our play merited.  
 

It's a game and there to be contested and I’m reasonably happy with how we did that tonight. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Motherwellfc1991 said:

I haven’t looked at comparable facts and stats but it must be close 

It’s a hard watch under Alfred- Possesion is only across the back and not positive or progressive to the middle or front 3rd and the resultant hoof ball to a lone striker is similar 

Based on what I’ve seen we won’t pick up many points away from home pre Xmas so our next 3 home games will determine if we are propping up the table by Xmas/new year , that being the case I wouldn’t have any confidence in him or him spending cash on new signings 

I could be totally wrong but I reckon Kanga is only signing AJ recommended,  the rest probably from nick Daws.    I think a lot have already made their minds up about AJ and of course that's their opinion and fully entitled.   Personally I think he needs a full season

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, johnstone said:

Paulsen was incredible tonight. Anyone doubting him needs a rethink. 

I think we will be fine this season. Just need a bit more up front. Maybe Henry will give us something.

Top six is achievable, we came up against a decent side today, unlucky to not get the point. 

What missing this season is confidence, we can’t seem to move the ball from the 18 yard line through the midfield like we did last season. 
 

Keep the faith.

 

You're almost as positive as me. Pair of us will be getting kicked out the forum! 🤣🤣

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, johnstone said:

Paulsen was incredible tonight. Anyone doubting him needs a rethink. 

I think we will be fine this season. Just need a bit more up front. Maybe Henry will give us something.

Top six is achievable, we came up against a decent side today, unlucky to not get the point. 

What missing this season is confidence, we can’t seem to move the ball from the 18 yard line through the midfield like we did last season. 
 

Keep the faith.

 

Honestly agree. We weren't/aren't great right now but I didn't think tonight we were as bad as has been said. The worst possible start but we got the goal and grew into the game. We created a few chances and got into some decent positions that could/should have seen us take a lead. Agree that the introduction of Thor was puzzling. A lot of complaining around me about us retreating into our own half and as frustrating as it is they dictated that with their dominance of the ball. You can't simply push up the park when you're struggling to gain possession. All you're doing then is leaving huge gaps at the back to exploit. We were unlucky not to take a point tonight and make no mistake, rangers had to work like dogs to get the three.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now that the dust has settled my calmer thoughts on the game

 

Despite some of the over the top comments

1. we were not as bad as some are making out

2.There were spells in the game when we played some decent stuff

3. Yes Rangers could have scored 4 goals but thats what we pay our keeper and defence to do , to stop them scoring 4 goals. If you think Rangers are EVER going to come to Fir Park and not have more chances than us you are delusional. 

4. It took one jammy fuck goal to beat us, had the ball not hit Moorman it was going wide of the far post , thats how bad the Rangers player struck it. 

5. We could have been 2-1 up before the late Ranger onslaught.

6. If you are going to FP thinking you will ever see another season like last year you'd be as well not going , its not happening.

7. We gave the ball away too often, our passing accuracy percentage was in the mid 70s. For us to be effective it needs to be the mid 80s and thats where it was most of last season.

8. We need to address the forward line in the January window as PH and Maswanhise aint going to cut it.

9. We need to get a genuine right back , its not Sparrows position and hes being hung out to dry,

10. We need Lowry , Said and McGinn in the team.

11. we are 4 points off bottom and 4 points off 6th 

I thoroughly expected a scudding tonight, we didn't get one so we have to build on that. As Ive said before Im not 100% convinced about the manager and that remains without wanting him sacked right now. Our next 5 games are 

Hibs - Home

Falkirk - Away 

Kilmarnock - Home

Hearts - Away

Dundee - Home 

We need 8/9 points from that run , if we get it we will be mid table , if we don't we could very well be in bother this season.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Manager gives another boring predictable interview. You could have played one from 6 weeks sgo and no one would noticed the difference. Called him a fraud weeks ago and I stand by that. Smoke and mirrors and no substance. Also our squad is a Championship squad. A third of the way through the season 14 games played and fuck all improvement. A poor manager and a squad packed full of very very poor players. We lack fitness, tackling ability, strength, power, pace, goal scoring ability and defensive capability. We are a total  shambles on the park 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, FirParkCornerExile said:

Now that the dust has settled my calmer thoughts on the game

 

Despite some of the over the top comments

1. we were not as bad as some are making out

2.There were spells in the game when we played some decent stuff

3. Yes Rangers could have scored 4 goals but thats what we pay our keeper and defence to do , to stop them scoring 4 goals. If you think Rangers are EVER going to come to Fir Park and not have more chances than us you are delusional. 

4. It took one jammy fuck goal to beat us, had the ball not hit Moorman it was going wide of the far post , thats how bad the Rangers player struck it. 

5. We could have been 2-1 up before the late Ranger onslaught.

6. If you are going to FP thinking you will ever see another season like last year you'd be as well not going , its not happening.

7. We gave the ball away too often, our passing accuracy percentage was in the mid 70s. For us to be effective it needs to be the mid 80s and thats where it was most of last season.

8. We need to address the forward line in the January window as PH and Maswanhise aint going to cut it.

9. We need to get a genuine right back , its not Sparrows position and hes being hung out to dry,

10. We need Lowry , Said and McGinn in the team.

11. we are 4 points off bottom and 4 points off 6th 

I thoroughly expected a scudding tonight, we didn't get one so we have to build on that. As Ive said before Im not 100% convinced about the manager and that remains without wanting him sacked right now. Our next 5 games are 

Hibs - Home

Falkirk - Away 

Kilmarnock - Home

Hearts - Away

Dundee - Home 

We need 8/9 points from that run , if we get it we will be mid table , if we don't we could very well be in bother this season.

Well said 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Kmcalpin said:

It strikes me, from what I've seen, and from others' comments, that AJ hasn't got a clue as to how to set up the midfield. 

completely. There’s been several games where the opposition has added a 4th man to their midfield and were left short .

the answer has generally been to reduce to 2 man midfield and add Thor or other strikers - therefore punt it up but nothing sticks .

We’re not getting the best out of wingbacks , midfield or forward players - given the position it seems fairly obvious to test a back 3, push wingbacks forward to connect better with forwards .

bottom line we deserve to be bottom 3 and suspect we’ll stay there. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Watching the highlights back and some of the saves from Paulsen were nothing short of outstanding. He is the one player to come out of last night with any pass marks because him apart we weren’t at the races and if we’re being honest had we sneaked a draw it would have been daylight robbery.

I’m not expecting us to be beating or competing with Rangers who are a far superior team to us, but we literally have nothing in the way of attacking threat in that team. JGR’s goal last night was well taken but the fact that our last two goals were penalties speaks volumes because we were never scoring otherwise in those two games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Look at Falkirk. No bigger budget than hours. Now 6 wins in a row. Best form of any team in the league. No big signings. They caused us problems last season when Askou was the manager. We managed to field a team with not one Scottish player in the lineup. Falkirk fielded 5 Scottish players on their 2-1 defeat of St Johnstone. Their squad is similar to ours full of players who started of in lower leagues. The difference is McGinn knows Scottish football inside out and is tactically astute. They have a manager and we have a guy who thinks he is a manager

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, ppower said:

They have a manager and we have a guy who thinks he is a manager

Correct. I said as much the other week, McGlynn is a manager while AJ is a coach.

There is a snobbery among football fans in this country and not just our fanbase over appointing Scottish managers or Scottish based managers. “Don’t want to go down the merry go round with the usual suspects like McGlynn, Pressley, Neilson” etc all while being happy to accept some completely unknown face from abroad. Now granted it worked better than anyone could ever have hoped with Jens last season but that was very much the exception and it’s unlikely that ourselves or any other club of our size will strike gold like that again anytime soon. 
 

One of the best cases in point is Rangers with Del. He was under their noses for years at Kilmarnock and then Hearts while they brought in duds like Beale, Clement, Martin and Rohl and got nowhere. Now they have finally brought in Del they look very much the title contender and they will win at the very least one trophy this season. They have a manager who gets the league, gets the Scottish game and knows how to win here. It’s the same with Falkirk and McGlynn and Dundee with Pressley.

If/when we part company with AJ I would love to see us try and get Steve Clarke. I have no idea that he would want the job or even be remotely interested in it, but we should ask the question. Scotland are missing him already with their new “exciting and out of the box” foreign coach proving to be hopelessly out of touch and out of depth. Funny that? :rolleyes:

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wasn't on last night , surprised at some of the comments, expected a 50/50 response ,  but probably shouldn't be and who is making them.

First 20 mins poor, after that very competitive. 

Rangers deserved their win , spent lot more money, guess what , they have better players.

I reckon they will win the league.

We lost at least 4 very good players in Summer,  add Liwry and Said , we dont have an outball.

It took a jammy goal to beat us.

There are some tiresome negative peeps on here but we cant all be happy clappers.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, MJC said:

Correct. I said as much the other week, McGlynn is a manager while AJ is a coach.

There is a snobbery among football fans in this country and not just our fanbase over appointing Scottish managers or Scottish based managers. “Don’t want to go down the merry go round with the usual suspects like McGlynn, Pressley, Neilson” etc all while being happy to accept some completely unknown face from abroad. Now granted it worked better than anyone could ever have hoped with Jens last season but that was very much the exception and it’s unlikely that ourselves or any other club of our size will strike gold like that again anytime soon. 
 

One of the best cases in point is Rangers with Del. He was under their noses for years at Kilmarnock and then Hearts while they brought in duds like Beale, Clement, Martin and Rohl and got nowhere. Now they have finally brought in Del they look very much the title contender and they will win at the very least one trophy this season. They have a manager who gets the league, gets the Scottish game and knows how to win here. It’s the same with Falkirk and McGlynn and Dundee with Pressley.

If/when we part company with AJ I would love to see us try and get Steve Clarke. I have no idea that he would want the job or even be remotely interested in it, but we should ask the question. Scotland are missing him already with their new “exciting and out of the box” foreign coach proving to be hopelessly out of touch and out of depth. Funny that? :rolleyes:

And you are still talking pish. You have no idea how McGlynn or AJ operates on day to day basis and interactions with players for you to define who is a "manager" and who is a "coach". You just use word salad to create a case against a manager you dislike intensely. By all means continue to rail against AJ that is your choice and we all have them but for Christs sake at least base it on facts and not uniformed conjecture. You make a sweeping statement without one iota of fact to differentiate between a manager and a coach. To do so you'd need intimate knowledge of both operations and you have none. Ive said from early on I'm not convinced by AJ as yet but I prefer my criticisms to be based on facts. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

After being at the match last night and reading the comments on here im still a 50/50 with AJ.

I for one thought that having rode out the first 15 minutes and losing Said is worrying, we were in the game for a point or even a sneaky victory until  firstly RCC got hooked instead of Mas who offered nothing except passing to Rangers n falling down, yes he tracked back to help Sparrow but teams have identified Tom ain’t no RB and every attack singles him out but AJ still insists he’s a RB???
Tom is the major defensive weak link, Moorman I thought was outstanding last night and unlucky with that last minute deflection, Polsen had his best game in Motherwell colours last night but his distribution is still mince, great shot stopper but ask for a quick throw out or quick kick he’s so slow.

I think the biggest majority of the forum all accept AJ was never going to be Jens 2, nobody could replicate what he achieved with Well last year so we are in a time where we are not going to be in Feb title contenders but equally with the league at the moment we could be top 6 or bottom 3.

I do think the recruitment has been questionable and not addressing key areas given the money we spent.

We appear to have bought a perma crock in a critical position: Williams, up front we have not bought a decent striker, Seb is a project at best, I reckon he’s related to Ryan Bowman, 110% effort..no skill, Hodge is a decent player but played poor last night, RCC is nothing other than a sub, Thor..the poor guy needs a run in the starting line up to see what he can actually do, Levitt, he’s the same needs a run but I don’t think he’s better than Oscar or Faddy, JGR, appears solid enough but lacks pace, Moorman could be a signing but needs the likes of McGinn beside him to guide, JKL looks good and why he’s not starting or getting minutes is strange, Kanga looks good combining with Longo, Lowry is badly missed for his direct approach and Johnny is a strange one who just needs to have a sneeze n he’s out for 6 weeks but when he does play we don’t have the Sparrow fear.

And finally, AJ, I don’t understand many of his selections, his substitutions his tactics and I honestly don’t think he does either, suited for the Scottish game? Looking not but the next 2 games could see us bottom and if we go there I honestly think the board have a question to answer, I do believe that a winning run into far away we have to remember the money that the uglies n Tarts splurged in the summer so they will always have better players so for me our league is against the other 9, 2 wins in the next 2 sees us mid table and some confidence building…I hope!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, ppower said:

Look at Falkirk. No bigger budget than hours. Now 6 wins in a row. Best form of any team in the league. No big signings. They caused us problems last season when Askou was the manager. We managed to field a team with not one Scottish player in the lineup. Falkirk fielded 5 Scottish players on their 2-1 defeat of St Johnstone. Their squad is similar to ours full of players who started of in lower leagues. The difference is McGinn knows Scottish football inside out and is tactically astute. They have a manager and we have a guy who thinks he is a manager

Here`s his record at Hearts - 8 wins, 13 draws, and 14 losses (37 goals scored, 49 conceded). Not great eh?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, MJC said:

Correct. I said as much the other week, McGlynn is a manager while AJ is a coach.

There is a snobbery among football fans in this country and not just our fanbase over appointing Scottish managers or Scottish based managers. “Don’t want to go down the merry go round with the usual suspects like McGlynn, Pressley, Neilson” etc all while being happy to accept some completely unknown face from abroad. Now granted it worked better than anyone could ever have hoped with Jens last season but that was very much the exception and it’s unlikely that ourselves or any other club of our size will strike gold like that again anytime soon. 
 

One of the best cases in point is Rangers with Del. He was under their noses for years at Kilmarnock and then Hearts while they brought in duds like Beale, Clement, Martin and Rohl and got nowhere. Now they have finally brought in Del they look very much the title contender and they will win at the very least one trophy this season. They have a manager who gets the league, gets the Scottish game and knows how to win here. It’s the same with Falkirk and McGlynn and Dundee with Pressley.

If/when we part company with AJ I would love to see us try and get Steve Clarke. I have no idea that he would want the job or even be remotely interested in it, but we should ask the question. Scotland are missing him already with their new “exciting and out of the box” foreign coach proving to be hopelessly out of touch and out of depth. Funny that? :rolleyes:

No one on here cares about "Del" or Rangers!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 The facts are ....

We nearly held the top form team in the leauge who have miles better players than us to a draw, a deflected lucky goal stole them the points.

We played ok in spells even after loosing our in form attacker after just 10 mins.

We are not the finished artical by any means ,manager has to get with it the subs wrong ones again last night and AJ should be dropped pronto, hes totally rubbish and uninterested.

Need to start taking points from games no chucking them away. Confident we can improve.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, stv said:

 The facts are ....

We nearly held the top form team in the leauge who have miles better players than us to a draw, a deflected lucky goal stole them the points.

We played ok in spells even after loosing our in form attacker after just 10 mins.

We are not the finished artical by any means ,manager has to get with it the subs wrong ones again last night and AJ should be dropped pronto, hes totally rubbish and uninterested.

Need to start taking points from games no chucking them away. Confident we can improve.

Do you not mean JT? 🤣

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...