Jump to content

weeyin

Moderator
  • Posts

    23,824
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    583

Everything posted by weeyin

  1. Agreed. I hope JBA sorts that out.
  2. Never thought I'd see the day when I wanted 2 St Mirren players to stay on the park - and one of them was Gogic.
  3. Unless he scratched his eye with a fingernail, there was nothing in that for even a yellow. VAR should have sorted that one out.
  4. The current wording of the rule: "Where a player commits an offence against an opponent within their own penalty area which denies an opponent an obvious goal-scoring opportunity and the referee awards a penalty kick, the offender is cautioned if the offence was an attempt to play the ball or a challenge for the ball; in all other circumstances (e.g. holding, pulling, pushing, no possibility to play the ball etc.), the offending player must be sent off." So he probably thought it wasn't an obvious goal-scoring opportunity - which is probably true as the ball was going out. Although I have read that wording 3 times now, and I'm not exactly sure.
  5. He should, but gives us the chance to go at him in the second half.
  6. Playing some good stuff considering the opposition and conditions. Hope Fergie is enjoying it.
  7. Now, of course, JT should be in Gogic's face for the rest of the game.
  8. Nah, Fadinger's was fast, high and late. It was the high that did him.
  9. As much as I hate Gogic, I think it should be a yellow.
  10. Gogic doing to Slattery what he did to Just a Fir Park.
  11. Not sure what JT did to Gogic, but well played.
  12. So it's his right foot that's his shooting foot. Explains a lot.
  13. Not the Hollywood ending he was hoping for (5 - 3 defeat). Turnbull's Cardiff City also on the wrong end of a 5 -2 .
  14. I'd say we were about 40/60 to finish top 3. All depends on our away form.
  15. The thing that annoys me most about the Champions League is teams that win their domestic title but have to enter the competition at qualifying rounds. Meanwhile, other teams that finish 2nd or 3rd enter later in the competition. I know the competition has been dead an buried as a proper Cup since the big teams ganged up and decided getting knocked out in a early round wasn't fair to them (or their bank balance), but they could at least have all the Champions qualify automatically and enter at the same stage. I used to really enjoy the European Cup when it was 2-leg straight knock out. as it felt like a genuine competition. Now it's just yet another league that's manufactured to ensure the big teams win and are further enriched. I barely watch any of the games these days.
  16. "Team news?" "At least Oscar is fresh"
  17. weeyin

    Red Card Law

    This all depends on having competent people wanting to be referees. I'm not sure how many sane individuals would want to make that career move. Worth a try though.
  18. I'm surprised he wasn't one of the ones out the door in the summer or January. Didn't have much confidence in him in the old system, never mind the new one. I don't think he'll start, but I imagine Eythor might get some extended game time in this one to give his regards to the St Mirren defence..
  19. Sorry about that; fixed it now - think of it as MOTM load balancing.
  20. weeyin

    Red Card Law

    It all goes back to competence of referees and their ability to understand the game and the context of the game. IFAB have tried remove the need for referees to figure out intent, which is why we ended up with the ridiculous handball rules. The same goes for the situation for Priestman where the rules have tried to create absolutes rather than taking context into account. If the refs could be trusted to understand and appreciate footballing situations, we could let them apply common sense. Sadly, I don't see that changing any time soon. On a slightly different note, regarding "ruining games for the paying public", I completely agree with that. I've often wondered if it wouldn't be better to allow a red-carded player to be replaced with, perhaps, harsher punishments for those that are red carded. In a sport that has tried many things to be more entertaining, a team going down to 10 men early in a game can spoil the spectacle for both sets of fans. I know things like sin-bins have been trialled, but maybe that would another option for the Priestman situation. 15 minutes off the pitch. Or instead of a red card, always book the player and award a penalty even if it wasn't inside the box. There must be a better option, even if it's not perfect.
×
×
  • Create New...