Motherwells Greatest 100

[SteelmaninOZ]

27 minutes ago, MFCL84 said:

Any list would have to include Tommy Coyne, James McFadden, Davie Cooper, Phil O'Donnell, Keith McCrae, Joe Wark, Willie Pettigrew, Bobby Graham, Bobby Watson, Brian Heron, Vic Davidson, Paul Lambert, Brian Martin, etc.....

Good list there to start 👍

[Kmcalpin]

I've arbitrarily identified about 105 candidates so far but it'll take quite some time to sort out an order. Criteria, for me, are appearances, goals scored and international appearances. Its obviously difficult to rate players from bygone eras that I've never seen, and avoid recency bias. 

[Mad Dog]

....and Tommy Boyd?

[Orinoco]

He just missed out! He is down at number 666

[yosemite sam]

11 minutes ago, Orinoco said:

He just missed out! He is down at number 666

He must have moved up, I'm sure he was at 1034.

[Kmcalpin]

34 minutes ago, Mad Dog said:

....and Tommy Boyd?

I thought long and hard about him and he'll be in my best 100, due solely to his on the field performances. .  

[weeyin]

Sometimes you need to separate the art from the artist.

I watched Tom Boyd lift the Scottish Cup, and everyone involved in that campaign should be a candidate.

I give zero stuffs what he did after that.

[mio]

I’m sure he must have done at some point but personally I have never heard him say one positive thing about Motherwell.

considering I watched a couple of seasons pre-cooper of him aimlessly running around midfield, I think I deserve an apology at least.

[Spiderpig]

2 hours ago, weeyin said:

 

I give zero stuffs what he did after that.

Most people feel the same but the mans an obnoxious prick as soon as he joined Celtic his previous career did not exist, as a member of the 91 team he should be a club legend, but going full darkside and turning into a fud in doing so means he should be nowhere near the list.